The Kremenets Theophany Convent was the defendant in case No. 921/619/23, brought by the Kremenets-Pochaiv State Historical and Architectural Reserve; the court decisions name it the Holy Theophany Convent of the Ternopil Eparchy of the UOC. According to the Supreme Court's resolution, the Commercial Court of Ternopil Oblast ruled on 24 July 2025 that the convent must return to the Reserve the Complex of Buildings of the Theophany Monastery in Kremenets: the Theophany Cathedral and the cell block, both of 1760, and a twentieth-century bell tower, with a total area of 3,218 square metres. The court rejected in full the convent's counterclaim to have agreement No. 5 of 3 September 2018 on the free use of state property declared invalid, and on 6 May 2026 the Western Commercial Court of Appeal left that decision unchanged.
On 13 October 2026 the Commercial Cassation Court of the Supreme Court dismissed the convent's cassation appeal and left both decisions unchanged. It also found no grounds to suspend the proceedings until a decision enters into force in another case the convent is pursuing over part of the premises of the cell block. The resolution states that it is final and not subject to appeal.
That other case is No. 910/13603/25, in which the convent sought to recover into its ownership, from the possession of the Ministry of Culture of Ukraine, premises with a total area of 591.5 square metres in the cell block. The Commercial Court of Kyiv City dismissed the claim on 29 April 2026, and on 14 October 2026 the Northern Commercial Court of Appeal dismissed the convent's appeal and left that decision unchanged. In its resolution the appellate court found that the disputed premises form part of a cultural heritage monument, the Complex of Buildings of the Theophany Monastery.
Sources: Unified State Register of Court Decisions, resolution of the Supreme Court of 13 October 2026 in case No. 921/619/23; resolution of the Northern Commercial Court of Appeal of 14 October 2026 in case No. 910/13603/25.


