Do not look back! (a chapter from Abbess Feofila's book "Плач третьей птицы")
Do not look back! (a chapter from Abbess Feofila's book "Плач третьей птицы")
The first thought of monasticism: untried, somewhat naive, with an admixture of ascetic romanticism, not yet grown strong at all, but pure. How often this fresh impulse of the soul withers under the pressure of an endless stream of thoughts: which monastery to choose, whom to consult, from whom to take a blessing... In a word, what to do when one has not yet learned to hear and understand the voice of one's calling. Or all this is a divided soul — the infirmity of a faith that fears to follow Christ to the end. "No man, having put his hand to the plough, and looking back, is fit for the kingdom of God." He who looks back is already turning back, already betraying love... 

There is an opinion that before leaving for a monastery one absolutely must receive a blessing from one's spiritual father, or better still from an elder. Yet the history of monasticism holds not all that many examples of turning to a spiritual father beforehand. Alexander Grenkov, the future St Ambrose of Optina, travelled to Elder Hilarion of Troekurovo, but even after receiving a definite instruction, even with a direction where to go, he still, in his own words, hung back for a long time. So too the famous Abbess Feofania (Gotovtseva) of Goritsy: years passed between the blessing and its fulfilment. Far more often the future saints, insofar as the Lives are reliable, left suddenly, straight from the place where God's call overtook them, conferring not with flesh and blood. St Cyriacus, when at the Liturgy the words of the Saviour reached him, If any man will come after me…, without looking in at home, ran to the harbour and sailed from Corinth to Jerusalem on the first ship.

Simeon the Stylite likewise left suddenly, having once heard the Beatitudes. Blessed Augustine touches on a striking case in the Confessions: a secret informer, one of the courtiers, came upon a hut during a walk, where he found a little book, the Life of St Anthony, read a little of it and at once made up his mind: to exchange the honorary title of "friend of the emperor" that awaited him for the rank of a friend of God — in monasticism. St Gurias of Kazan rethought his life while in prison; finding the door unlocked one day, he went, with no spiritual fathers at all, straight to the Joseph‑Volokolamsk Monastery.

Further, people advise choosing a monastery that is already well established and not poor, so that the struggle for survival and the heavy labours it brings do not predominate there; that is, preference is recommended for a monastery already set up, restored and, as a rule, historically famous, so as to bask in the rays of its former glory, to live, as St Anthony the Great foretold, not in caves and huts but in magnificent buildings… to care for luxurious food… to boast of their fathers. At the same time there must on no account be any material dependence on sponsors, because the latter, interfering in the monastic way of life, disrupt it, and besides, who knows where their money comes from.

Finally, it is held that one should leave gradually. You like a monastery — go there for visits, first for three short days, then stay on for a week, a month, three months, until you come to desire to remain forever. Perhaps that is possible too, it depends on temperament, but it is rare. E., who was getting ready to go to Pühtitsa (1979), pondered nothing of the kind; "if only they take me! Lord, if only they take me!"… Indeed: if the heart is burning, is there any room for far-reaching calculations — whether there will be enough means, strength, enthusiasm — as if you were about to buy furniture or spend a holiday abroad.

In former times, in choosing a monastery, people thought not of comforts; "they looked for where the life would be harsh, chose the longer services — at the Sarov Hermitage… No, still too easy; they went to Father Theodore at Sanaksar, a monastery without a wall, fenced with a paling, the church small, little sliding-shutter windows, inside even the walls unhewn, and there were not even any candles: they read in church by the light of a splinter"…

They sought the will of God; Metropolitan Nikolai (Mogilevsky) tells how, at the very beginning of the twentieth century, he solved the problem of choice: he bought a thick book describing the monasteries of Russia and prayed: may the Lord Himself direct me wherever He pleases; and with that he went to bed; in the morning he brushed against the book, it fell and opened at the Nilo‑Stolobensky Hermitage.

The numerous and manifold ramblings about bad times, spiritual impoverishment and the ailments of monasticism are always veiled and ennobled with quotations from the writings of Bishop Ignatius (Brianchaninov). Whoever falls upon monasticism, progressives in the nineteenth century, atheists in the twentieth or, above all, pessimists in the twenty-first, invariably use the name and the word of St Ignatius as a crushing club.

But why not, for balance and objectivity, turn to another witness of the same rank and the same time, Bishop Theophan: "To say that the monasteries have lost their significance is sinful. It is a lie… Go into any monastery you like: outwardly everything there is seemly, but whether it is so within as well — who can speak of that? God alone and the conscience of those who live in the monastery; outside judges of this do not escape the sin of unrighteous condemnation and slander… I believe you will not find a single nun or a single monk who has no care at all for a good inner disposition… but success is not the same for all."

And St Ignatius himself, while admitting that "the monastic life has weakened, as has Christian life in general", nevertheless affirmed: "the monasteries, as institutions of the Holy Spirit, still send forth rays of light into Christendom; there is still food there for the pious; there is still the keeping of the Gospel commandments there; there is still there a strict Orthodoxy, both dogmatic and moral; there, though rarely, extremely rarely, living tablets of the Holy Spirit are found" (let us note in parentheses that universally recognised "living tablets of the Holy Spirit" have not been found all that often in the whole history of monasticism and Christianity).

A tendentious selection of quotations can create the impression that Bishop Ignatius, disillusioned with the monasticism of his own day, considered his youthful choice a mistake, censured monasteries in principle and regarded their way of life merely as an object of criticism. But that is not so at all! The saint loved the monastic houses with all his heart: "spiritual host! May the blessing of heaven descend upon you because you have loved heaven!.. Brethren! You have chosen that good part! Do not look back, do not be drawn to the world again… hold fast to this haven!". He himself remained in a monastery until his death, although, as an aristocrat by birth and a retired bishop, he could probably have chosen something more comfortable to live in, and certainly would not have feared to abandon a "wrong" path, had he considered it such.

And surely one cannot regard Optina, Valaam, Borodino and other monasteries, whose high significance has been attested by contemporaries and by history, as devoid of monastic endeavour, morally decayed, unspiritual, on the strength of a preference for one opinion; the most rapturous veneration of a saint does not, as is well known, exclude his human shortcomings and sometimes errors, and why not admit it: Bishop Ignatius followed a path far from ordinary, one that hardly anyone, even knowing the final outcome, would recommend repeating: within a short time he changed several monasteries, dissatisfied now with the crowds, now with the company, now with the food, now with the climate; at twenty-five, without having passed through the school of obedience, he became, through the intervention of the powerful of this world, a superior, and then sought to leave the flock entrusted to him because of slanders and hostility.

Of course, the holy bishop, thanks to his education and culture, understood more clearly than others how far the monastic reality before him fell short of the patristic ideal: he knew repentance and felt this shortfall in himself; his sensitive, gentle, delicate soul suffered and wept with pain. Fr Georges Florovsky points to St Ignatius's resistance to the mystical influences of the Alexandrine era, permeated by a deluded, illusory, unsober, hasty spirituality poisoned by pride; but, strangely, features of that same era were reflected in his own personal make-up as well: this, perhaps, explains the whole sharpness of his negations: a struggle with himself.

The same author cites the testimony of a foreigner who visited the Sergius Hermitage in 1840; W. Palmer quotes sharp critical remarks by its superior, Archimandrite Ignatius, about hypocritical orthodoxy and even the deadness of the Church, which preserves only a fine exterior, symbols and rites. But the accusations concerned only the white clergy, infected with the spirit of heretical liberalism.

The saint undoubtedly always gave preference to monasticism faithful to the patristic tradition, and, "approaching the end of the earthly pilgrimage", unequivocally concluded: "as a spiritual good, embracing and uniting in itself all other goods, I name monasticism, to which I was called from childhood by a wondrous calling and ineffable mercy."

 See the full version of the article in the book by Abbess Feofila (Lepeshinskaya), "Плач третьей птицы"


Published:

← Publications


Call us