The threefold light of spiritual ascetic labour
The mind of a person who has come to love God and has felt the fear of losing Him strives always to be with Him. But "it is impossible," says St Maximus the Confessor, "for the mind to be always with the one God unless it acquires… love, abstinence and prayer. Love subdues anger, abstinence dries up lust, and prayer, detaching the mind from all thoughts, presents it naked to God Himself. These three virtues contain within themselves all righteousness…".
The other Fathers too reduce to these three great generic concepts of perfection the whole complexity of their teaching on the ascetic labour of the Christian path.
"If you wish to attain salvation, renounce fleshly pleasures and take up abstinence, love and prayer" (abba Thalassius).
"It is impossible for the mind to be at peace in prayer unless it first acquires fellowship with abstinence and love…" (St Elias the Presbyter).
The venerable Seraphim also spoke of these three forms of perfection: "The true purpose of our Christian life consists in the acquisition of the Spirit of God. I wish you always to be in the grace of the Holy Spirit, to acquire it by the means of which I have already told you, and to consider which means gives you more of the grace of the Holy Spirit, and to occupy yourselves with that means: Divine prayer and vigil give you more grace — keep vigil and pray; fasting gives much of the Spirit of God — fast; almsgiving gives more — give alms" (the venerable Seraphim).
It is quite possible that here the venerable Seraphim is also indicating that there exist some three basic types of spiritual character, that is, that people practising the Christian ascetic labour may have a spiritual predisposition either to "fasting" or to "almsgiving", or to prayer.
Abba John the Prophet has words that convey the same thought. "As a craftsman," he says, "who knows his craft well and, because of the quickness of his mind, practises other crafts as well, is not called a master of them, but only a master of his own craft, so also here one who has all the virtues is known by that one and takes his name from that one through which the grace of the Spirit shines most brightly in him".
At the same time, the threefold nature of spiritual characters is not a dismemberment of the one image. There are diversities of gifts, but the same Spirit; and there are differences of administrations, but the same Lord; and there are diversities of operations, but it is the same God which worketh all in all (1 Cor. 12:4–6, King James Version). In every individual path a triunity will be built, beyond comprehension. The one who goes chiefly by the path of prayer will sooner or later, easily or after hard trials, understand that without abstinence his prayer is barren. And both the one who prays and the one who goes chiefly by the path of abstinence will inevitably understand also that without love for people everything dies: both abstinence and prayer. And this is so not only in the sense of the general path, but also with regard to each separate spiritual step. The one who has risen in the morning to pray knows that prayer is easiest when it is performed before taking food: abstinence has given wings to prayer. And he knows too that if during prayer he does not enter into some bosom of love for people and does not forgive those who have grieved him, then the Heavenly Father will not forgive him either and will not accept his prayer. Only in threefold unity can a person go his own particular way. Whosoever shall keep the whole law — says the Apostle — and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all (Jas. 2:10, King James Version). The three generic concepts of perfection — love for people, abstinence and prayer — merge into a single image of the path, being themselves the development of that triune feeling which has formed in a person towards God: love for Him, humility before Him, and renunciation of the world for His sake. Love for God proves itself by love for people, humility before Him finds its breath in prayer, renunciation of the world for His sake renounces evil in abstinence. A candle lit before God kindles with a threefold reflection in a person's soul. If a person has loved his Lord without falsehood, then with the same sincerity he will go to these three forms of perfection, recognising them as a single path to Him. This is the acceptance, in the ascetic labour of love, of the whole Gospel, when it becomes the single law of indivisible perfection.
Help from above
Ascetic labour is movement towards God. But the aspiration of a path begun is by no means enough for traversing it. Only the grace of God — the Fathers teach — has the strength and power to accomplish the threefold union of perfection towards which a person must courageously direct himself.
"None of us," says St Theodore of Edessa, "can by his own strength escape the circumventions and wiles of the evil one, but only by the invincible power of Christ. Therefore those who dream of abolishing sin by the ascetic labours they perform and by the force of their own will are dangerously mistaken, for sin is abolished by the grace of God alone. That is why John Chrysostom, a luminary of the Church, says that the effort of man alone is not enough if help from above is not received; and again — there will be no benefit from help from above if there is no effort of one's own".
"…The soul can resist sin, but cannot conquer without God…" (the venerable Macarius the Great).
"Know that if you do not use all your efforts to overcome your passion, you will not receive help from God, and if, striving with all zeal, you rely on your own strength alone, you will have no success whatever. Strive, and strive with all zeal, but expect success from the help of God alone. Help will come without fail and, making your powerless efforts all-powerful, will give you an easy victory" (the venerable Nicodemus of the Holy Mountain).
"As a body without a soul is dead and cannot do anything, so without a heavenly soul, without the Spirit of God, the soul too is dead to the kingdom, and without the Spirit it cannot do what is of God" (the venerable Macarius the Great).
"Blessed is he who has truly realised that God in us, as in instruments, accomplishes every deed and contemplation, virtue and knowledge, victory and wisdom, goodness and truth, so that we contribute absolutely nothing to this of ourselves, except one thing — a disposition that desires the good…" (the venerable Maximus the Confessor).
The Divine help was recognised as so immeasurably surpassing the labour of the ascetic that the significance of that labour lay only in showing the direction of the will, in showing that a person had desired God and had set out towards Him. Ascetic labour proves only the free "yes" spoken by a person's life to the incorruptible life of God, and not a right to it or a possession of it. This "yes" is spoken out by the great struggle of the soul throughout the whole of life. The stronger it is and the deeper a person's love for God, the stronger the ascetic labour of life. And to this "yes" — strong or weak — the gates of grace are opened for help and guidance.
A disciple asked Barsanuphius the Great: "God created man free, and He Himself says: without me ye can do nothing (John 15:5, King James Version). I ask: how can freedom be reconciled with the fact that nothing can be done without God? The elder replied: 'God created man free, that he might incline to the good; and once inclined to it by his own choice, he is not able to accomplish the good without the help of God'".
"The acquisition of virtue and knowledge is achieved not by our own natural powers, but by grace" (St Maximus the Confessor).
Without grace — without the light-bearing power of God — the Christian path is impossible.
"Every hour and minute we need the help of God… Pray, then, always and sigh to the Lord, that He may give you His grace and keep you in it: the grace of God (we) need every minute" (St Tikhon of Zadonsk).
Retaining grace
"Abba Arsenius (the Great) said: if we seek God, He will appear to us, — and if we hold Him within us, He will abide with us".
The "seeking" and "retaining" of God within oneself is the ascetic labour of purifying oneself.
"The Holy Virgin, overshadowed by the Spirit, conceived and bore in Her womb the Son of God who became man: likewise those Christians upon whom the grace of the Holy Spirit descends mysteriously conceive and bear in their hearts the Son of God by the action of the Holy Spirit" (the venerable abba Isaiah).
"The purpose of the Christian life consists in the acquisition of the Spirit of God, and this is the purpose of the life of every Christian who lives spiritually… Fasting, vigil, prayer, virginity and all the other virtues done for the sake of Christ, however good they are in themselves, yet it is not in them alone that the purpose of our Christian life consists, and we were not born merely to do them; but the purpose of our life is that grace of the Spirit of God which they bring us, and it is in the acquisition of that grace alone (obtained through them) that the purpose of the Christian life consists" (the venerable Seraphim).
"The Holy Spirit, condescending to our weakness, comes to us even when we are not yet pure; and if only He finds our mind sincerely praying to Him, He comes upon it and scatters the whole crowd of thoughts and imaginings that surrounds it… thereby disposing it to a longing for spiritual prayer" (the venerable Nilus of Sinai).
"When you read the Divine Scriptures, do not have in mind merely to read through leaf after leaf, but with reflection enter into every word, and when certain words make you sink deeper into yourself, or produce a movement of contrition, or fill your heart with spiritual joy and love, — stop at them. It is God who draws near to you; humbly receive Him with an open heart, for He Himself wills that you partake of Him... Have no other aim than to find God, wherever He is pleased to reveal Himself to you. And when you are granted this, cease every other work and do not move forward in it, — forget everything else, and rest in your one God. But when it shall please His majesty to withdraw from you and to cease to show His nearness to you on this occasion, then you may again return to your usual spiritual exercises (practices) and continue them, keeping in view the same aim, that is, to find through them your Beloved" (the venerable Nicodemus of the Holy Mountain).
"The loss of grace is more terrible than all losses; there is no more wretched state than that of a person who has lost grace. One must maintain unceasing vigilance in order to preserve it. It is given to us freely, by the sole mercy of God, but for its preservation we must apply all our diligence" (Elder Parthenius of the Kyiv Caves).
"Lord, never allow us to be deprived of Your divine grace" — cries Symeon the Pious. A prayer for the return of lost grace has also been preserved from him: "…may Your grace enter again into Your servant, that, seeing it, he may rejoice with compunction and tears, being enlightened by its ever-bright radiance".
The futility of labours without faith
The permeation of the whole of asceticism with the light of the teaching on grace makes the very concept of ascetic labour luminous. Yet we are not very fond of this word, and, I think, not only because we do not love the narrow way to the Kingdom of God. The examples of false ascetic labour that we have seen or heard of have put us off it entirely. Let us recall, for instance, Elder Ferapont from "The Brothers Karamazov", whose prototypes, great and small, have always been found among those engaged in ascetic labour. The venerable Nicetas Stethatos has such words about them: "Many faithful and zealous Christians have exhausted their bodies with many ascetic toils; but since in doing so they have no compunction from a contrite and good-loving heart and no mercy from love for their neighbours and for themselves, they are left empty, deprived of the fullness of the Holy Spirit and removed from the true knowledge of God, having their mental wombs barren and their word saltless and lightless".
"I know monks who, after many labours, fell and lost their minds because they had relied on their own works" (the venerable Anthony the Great).
By the works of the law shall no flesh be justified (Gal. 2:16, King James Version), but only by faith which worketh by love (Gal. 5:6, King James Version). We have access by faith into this grace (Rom. 5:2, King James Version). Here it may be pointed out that the holy Fathers, who spent their lives in great ascetic toils, left us the teaching on the possibility of acquiring grace even without the usual toils of bodily ascetic labour, but only on account of faith and the love that proved it.
Thus ascetic toil, according to the teaching of the ascetic Fathers, is not always an obligatory condition for the acquisition of grace, that is, of the only saving power of God. Only faith saves, and this saving quality of faith may sometimes prove itself outside the usual toils of bodily ascetic labour: in love, in prayer and in humility. But this path is not the usual and common one, but a special one, "by the unfathomable dispositions of the Providence of God", and St Isaac the Syrian teaches that it must not be sought.
One must not demand anything "special" for oneself. One must walk, according to one's strength, the common path of humble effort, proving, in the sweat and toil of life, one's faith in God's saving sacrifice.
Fulfilment of the commandments
Ascetic labour is the fulfilment of the commandments of the Gospel. This is precisely how the Fathers understand the term:
"Ascetic labours are nothing distinct from the commandments," writes St Mark the Ascetic. "They are the commandments. Show me ascetic labours other than the commandments. If you point to prayer — that is a commandment; if you speak of the casting down of thoughts — that too is a commandment (be sober, be vigilant); if of fasting and vigil — that also is a commandment… and whatever deed of ascetic virtue you may name — they are all commandments".
"They asked abba John Kolobos what a monk is. He answered: compelling oneself to every commandment of God constitutes the distinguishing mark of a monk. One who lives thus is a monk". Thus ascetic labour is a synonym for the fulfilment of the commandments.
And although the burden of Christ is light, at the same time this is not the lightness of a cool life with an undemanding and even pleasant performance of certain ritual forms and moral rules, but the narrow way of the Cross. Consequently, ascetic labour is the traversing of the narrow way, which leadeth unto life (Matt. 7:14, King James Version), and the narrow way means sorrow. Apart from the sorrow of the soul there is no path to the Kingdom of God: a woman when she is in travail hath sorrow (John 16:21, King James Version).
"If you do not give blood, you will not receive the Spirit," teach the blessed Callistus and Ignatius. The Apostle speaks of the same: "Ye have not yet resisted unto blood, striving against sin" (Heb. 12:4, King James Version). To fulfil the commandments unto the blood of the soul means to accept them as life's own blood-matter, as its ascetic labour.
But the main thing is that when a person approaches — here on earth, amid his affairs and cares — the gates of the Kingdom of grace, he remembereth no more the anguish, for joy that a man is born into the world (John 16:21, King James Version). Then, says St Isaac the Syrian, he will find "such sorrows as are sweeter than honey".
"When one brother asked St Anthony: why is it that when God, according to all Scripture, promises the soul higher goods, the soul is not constantly firm in seeking them, but turns aside to the transient, the corruptible and the unclean? — he answered: he who has not yet tasted the sweetness of heavenly goods has not yet cleaved to God with all his heart; therefore he returns to the corruptible" (the venerable Anthony the Great).
That is why all the Fathers consider that the greatest force, both teaching and strengthening a person in ascetic labour and giving him zeal and joy for traversing the path, is precisely the tasting of the Divine grace of the Holy Spirit.
"Strive so that grace may never, even for a moment, leave you because of your negligence. But when, having risen above stumbling, you are able to cross the wall of passionate thoughts…, do not prove ungrateful, failing to recognise in this a gift given to you from above; but confess with the Apostle, saying: not I, but the grace of God which was with me (1 Cor. 15:10, King James Version) has accomplished in me this victory" (the venerable John of Karpathos).
For the full version of the theological study, see the book by Sergei Iosifovich Fudel, "Путь Отцов".



Comments