The defendant in case No. 917/1259/25 is the Mgar Transfiguration Monastery near Lubny, named in the court documents as the Spaso-Preobrazhenskyi (Mharskyi) Monastery of the Poltava Eparchy of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church. According to the appellate court's resolution, on 24 June 2025 the head of the Lubny District Prosecutor's Office brought a claim before the Commercial Court of Poltava Oblast in the interests of the state, represented by the Poltava Oblast Military Administration, asking that the monastery be obliged to return immovable property to the state, including the Transfiguration Cathedral of 1682-1754 and the bell tower of 1837, an architectural monument of national significance. The Ministry of Culture of Ukraine is a third party to the case. On 26 March 2026 the first-instance court dismissed the claim in full.
On 12 October 2026 the Eastern Commercial Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal of the deputy head of the Poltava Oblast Prosecutor's Office and left the decision unchanged. The appellate court agreed with the first-instance court that the remedy the prosecutor had chosen, a claim to remove obstacles to the owner, does not match the remedy the law provides for this relationship and is ineffective, which is in itself a ground for dismissing the claim. Among the circumstances established by the courts, the resolution states that the disputed property left the state's possession through acts of state and local authorities in 1993 and has since been in the monastery's actual possession and use.
The full text of the resolution was drawn up on 21 October 2026. As it states, the resolution may be appealed to the Supreme Court within twenty days of the date the full text was drawn up.
Sources: Unified State Register of Court Decisions, resolution of the Eastern Commercial Court of Appeal of 12 October 2026 in case No. 917/1259/25.


