This is stated in a ruling by a judge of the Kyiv District Administrative Court of 16 October 2026 in case No. 320/18113/26, made in written proceedings. The case was brought by Holosiievo Protection of the Mother of God Monastery, which the ruling calls the monastery “Holy Protection Holosiivska Pustyn” of the Kyiv Metropolia of the Ukrainian Orthodox Church; the Kyiv Metropolia of the UOC was a third party on the plaintiff’s side. The plaintiff asked the court to declare unlawful and cancel order No. N-44/11 of 23 March 2026 of the State Service of Ukraine for Ethnopolitics and Freedom of Conscience (DESS) “On finding signs of affiliation of the monastery…”. The court opened the proceedings on 11 May 2026.
According to the ruling, the plaintiff considered, among other things, that DESS had not ensured its right to take part in the administrative proceedings and had used inadmissible evidence, and that the order contradicts Article 35 of the Constitution of Ukraine; in its response DESS opposed the claim, stating that the order was issued within its powers, on the grounds and in the manner provided for by the Constitution and the laws.
The court did not agree with the plaintiff’s claim that the order puts in question its existence as a religious organisation. It said that the legal consequences for the organisation are created not by the order finding signs of affiliation but by the prescription to remedy the violations, which obliges the organisation to remedy them within the period set by law (30 days of receipt), and later by a decision recognising the organisation as affiliated. The court called the order itself internal to the procedure: it records the results of the study and imposes no obligations on the organisation, and the assessment it contains can be reviewed on the organisation’s objections. Therefore, the court concluded, the order is an intermediate decision rather than an individual act and cannot be a separate subject of judicial challenge; the proceedings were closed under point 1 of part 1 of Article 238 of the Code of Administrative Procedure.
The ruling says that DESS issued the monastery prescription No. P-1 of 24 March 2026 with a deadline for remedying the violations of 27 April 2026. Later, as DESS reported, it recognised the monastery as affiliated with a foreign religious organisation whose activity in Ukraine is banned (report of 20 May 2026), and on 13 July 2026 the Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal opened proceedings in case No. 855/8/26 on its claim to terminate the monastery (announcement of 14 July 2026).
The ruling takes legal effect upon signing; it can be appealed to the Sixth Administrative Court of Appeal within fifteen days of signing.
Sources: Unified State Register of Court Decisions, ruling of the Kyiv District Administrative Court of 16 October 2026 in case No. 320/18113/26; DESS, report of 20 May 2026; DESS, announcement of 14 July 2026.


